You Be The Judge - Update I

Early results are in - the Honorable Robert E. Payne, is not well-respected by those who have registered their opinions.

54 individuals have participated in the Survey.

33 individuals have left comments.

Survey results are well, appalling: D's and F's with a smattering of C's.

Comments are well, again appalling:

As a practicing attorney for over 45 years and an avid follower of the litigation presided over by Judge Payne as well as other legal proceedings in which Rambus, Inc. has been involved, I am shocked and extremely disappointed for our judicial system by this judge's obviously biased . . .

payne is the best judge money can buy. . .

Judge Payne has proven to have a agenda . . .

He is a shameful and dishonorable person. He is a criminal. . .

Demonstrating impartiality, integrity and honesty? Allowing both parties to be heard? Is there a grade below "F"?

In his handling of the Rambus v Infineon patent infringement case Judge Payne has demonstrated for following. - Extreme bias for clients of McGuire Woods where he was a partner previous to his appointment to the Federal Bench.

Read the complete comments at Court House Forum linked here.

View the survey results at Court House Forum linked here.